McLoughlin, Oswald Emails from Jan. Show Building Tensions

Correspondence between the Collingswood superintendent and his estranged high school basketball coach glimpse a relationship that was turning rocky in early 2012.

Even if an independent investigation confirms that former boys' basketball coach Joseph McLoughlin was , those findings would be insufficient to overturn his dismissal, Superintendent Scott Oswald told Patch today.

The Collingswood superintendent was steadfast in his insistence that McLoughlin had been informed of the reasons for his nonrenewal , and that none of them was related to any suspicion of administrative or racial bias.

“The decision about the coaching position is a separate issue,” Oswald said. “I’m the guy who knows all the reasons the decisions were made. There was not one notion that has anything to do with the players on the court.”

Oswald told Patch Tuesday that just because board policy has tied his hands in the very public tete-a-tete doesn’t mean the decision to retain or release McLoughlin as the CHS basketball coach could have been made by anyone else.

“In any school district, if you’re not going to renew a teacher, a coach, the superintendent is the only person by law who makes that recommendation,” he said. “The only way to get a job, to lose a job, comes through me.”

‘Check your paranoia at the door’

at the June 2012 Board of Education meeting as to why McLoughlin would have been dismissed from his coaching position was the speculation that he was improperly recruiting players.

Last week, Patch received copies of correspondence from Oswald to Haddon Heights Athletic Director Joseph Cramp dated May 12, 2011. In the letter, Oswald clears McLoughlin of any allegedly improper recruitment.

Patch also received copies of an email exchange between Oswald and McLoughlin dated Jan. 20, 2012. The messages reference a basketball game between Collingswood and Audubon, during which senior Malik Clark received two technical fouls for hanging on the rim.

In the first email, McLoughlin explains to Oswald that Clark incurred one technical in an effort not to land on a player beneath him, and the other because he “is very inexperienced as a basketball player, not fully aware of all the rules.”

McLoughlin adds that he reprimanded Clark “loudly in front of the other players and coaches to make sure he understood what he did wrong.”

From there, Oswald’s response explores an apparently long-running conversation the two shared about the coach’s belief that CHS principal Ed Hill and athletic director Ronald Hamrick were systematically attempting to undermine his management of the team.

In his reply, Oswald advises McLoughlin “to monitor the behavior” of players on the court and “check this Hamrick/Hill paranoia at the door.”

“As I told you a dozen times last year, neither Ed [Hill] nor Ron [Hamrick] has ever not supported you in discussions with me,” Oswald wrote. “Never has the topic of changing basketball coaches come up in discussion.

“Your reaction last week to Ed in front of student athletes combined with hearing from a board member that parents in his own community are telling him that both Ed and Ron are out to get you brings back flashes of our discussions of last year,” Oswald wrote.

“It all causes unnecessary drama and diverts my attention from focusing on the academic achievement of our students.”

In closing, Oswald calls himself McLoughlin’s “number 1 supporter,” but admits that he is “considering asking” the coach “to take a year off” in 2013.

“I just can’t keep dealing with the ‘everyone is out to get me’ mentality,” Oswald wrote. “Perhaps we all need some time to reassess. Your talents are being overshadowed by your paranoia.”

‘We are in the dark’

Tuesday, Oswald attacked the idea that McLoughlin believed himself to be the victim of an administrative witch hunt.

“We’re in a school district,” Oswald said. “Nobody here is out to get anybody else. The district, the curriculum all run better when people just get along. If I’m telling you that [it] hasn’t happened, the stuff you are fearful of hasn’t happened.”

Oswald said that even in Clark’s two-technical game he didn’t hold McLoughlin responsible because students can be expected to make mistakes.

“That’s why we have teachers and coaches and stuff,” Oswald said. “I do hold the coach responsible for his reaction to that behavior.”

But Dennis G. Young, McLoughlin’s attorney, says that line of thinking wasn’t a part of any notification his client received on the matter; moreover, he says McLoughlin was never notified of his impending dismissal as coach.

“We are in the dark as to why Joe wasn’t renewed,” Young said. “Even after the June meeting when the issue was tabled, there was absolutely no contact that was done spearheaded by Dr. Oswald’s office as related to his nonrenewal.”

Young further maintains that his client was not renewed for failing to follow a directive “by his athletic director and his principal to play more white players over black players.

“When you don’t have a reason for nonrenewing the most successful basketball coach in Collingswood history and then you attempt to come up with certain reasons that don’t exist, you shouldn’t get away with this,” Young said.

Any investigation supplemental to the June meeting at which McLoughlin was not renewed, Young says, should have been conducted prior to the decision to remove the coach.

“It may or may not be a paranoia,” Young said, “but if I am the superintendent and I am literally considering recommending to my board that this coach take a year off because of a paranoia, then I damn well better look into these allegations before I recommend that to my board. I better be 100 percent sure that what I’m claiming is someone’s delusion is in fact a delusion.”

‘A full, thorough and fair investigation’

The one person right now who’s actually getting paid to sift through the facts is former Camden County prosecutor and Haddonfield Commissioner Ed Borden.

Borden underscored that he is still seeking input from anyone with first-hand knowledge of the case, including “administrators, employees of the district, people associated with Joe McLoughlin’s camp and family members” of Collingswood students and players.

He said he expects such individuals “would welcome” the opportunity to weigh in on the case.

“I certainly expect to do a full, thorough and fair investigation,” Borden said.

The timeline on the case accelerated somewhat earlier this month, however, when the NAACP filed a formal complaint on McLoughlin’s behalf with the Office of Civil Rights of the New Jersey Attorney General.

Within the next few weeks, Young said, McLoughlin and the Clark family also will file corresponding briefs.

“We absolutely want the attorney general’s office to look into this,” he said.

Borden said the request doesn’t alter his investigation, however.

“Anybody has a right to ask the attorney general’s office to intervene,” he said. “I would expect they would be supportive of the kind of work the Collingswood Board of Education took in getting an investigation done."

Oswald said that whatever the findings of Borden’s commission or the outcome of any state-led inquiry, he’s disappointed that things didn’t go differently with McLoughlin, and wearied by the back-and-forth.

“I respect the man’s talent,” Oswald said, “and the good things he’s done for kids? One-hundred percent respect. But there are other people in the school district whose contributions are minimized because of this.”

Mike King August 05, 2012 at 04:21 PM
If the supt dismissed the coach for a specific reason, he is required to state the reason in a formal evaluation, meet w/the coach in a post observation setting to explain what he should do to improve, and finally set up a time for another formal evaluation to determine if the coach made an honest effort to address the is sues stated in the first observation. Of course, the supt did none of this, and now Governor Christie's AG has been invited to the party in Collingswood. Make no mistake about it, the AG Office is very efficient and they owe it all to their close relationship w/Christie. It's possible they will use this situation to show the need for appointed BOEs not elected, combining small districts and eliminating overhead (admins who don't interact directly w/students), and reforms in teacher evaluation. Then all state funding will be tied to the above mentioned actions or you will lose it altogether. I wouldn't say your supt./BOE brought this upon you single handedly. I think the combined actions of boards of ed across the state over the long term have brought this upon education in general in NJ
GFY August 05, 2012 at 07:24 PM
Actually, the new coach was unaware of the racial makeup of the team. He was in the men's room doing his hair for most of the games.
GFY August 05, 2012 at 07:32 PM
Not only that, B, but someone who has such respect doesn’t release these obviously one sided emails. Note that only Mr. Oswald’s side is in this article and the emails are between two people so there is no question who provided them to the patch.
J August 05, 2012 at 09:29 PM
Haha who is this guy? Did you not get elected for the BOE? I think Christie would be better suited correcting all the wrongs of his republican big whig buddies. Christie is an elitist. I think the educational system was pretty solid prior to his involvement. I went to Jersey schools until 10th grade, and moved to Florida. I can honestly say the education I received in NJ was head and shoulders over my education in Fl. Now, NJ is sliding fast in their US rankings. Christie is a huge factor. This is not communist Russia, you can't appoint BOEs. What's next let's appoint the president? Better yet, lets become a dictatorship. Exactly, ELITIST!!
J August 05, 2012 at 09:36 PM
GYF, does he have good hair? Or, is he a prima donna? Who's next in line since I heard he played black kids.
GFY August 05, 2012 at 10:04 PM
First of all, it's GFY. Don't know who will be next. Mark Fuhrman I suppose.
CBW August 05, 2012 at 10:10 PM
The "man up above"? Who are you talking about? The janitors that sit on the roof? C'mon lets be real and actually separate church and state for once. Some of us don't want to hear your bible bullshit. Let the people do their jobs.
J August 05, 2012 at 10:32 PM
Good For You?
Matt Skoufalos (Editor) August 05, 2012 at 10:59 PM
Excuse me, GFY, what about the presentation of these e-mails is one-sided?
GFY August 05, 2012 at 11:09 PM
Are you serious? You think the coach presented emails where he was being called paranoid? Come on. You don't have to say where you got them. But it's ptrety obvious. The are from Oswald's side only.
GFY August 05, 2012 at 11:09 PM
Matt Skoufalos (Editor) August 05, 2012 at 11:18 PM
I know where they came from, GFY, and without saying where that is, I can tell you it wasn't from Oswald.
GFY August 05, 2012 at 11:33 PM
Okay, Matt. Whatever. I guess the coach sent you emails that made him look paranoid. Or they were'nt emails just between those two. But they are definitley one-sided. Can you honestly say they aren't? All the quotes are Oswald's.
insider August 05, 2012 at 11:35 PM
So that explains who cbw is,a person who uses Bible as an adjective for Bull.... If the people were doing their jobs they would not be spending $10,000 of tax payer's money to find out something that they could have prevented. Unless,doing their job is firing a coach who has had the most wins in Collingwood High School history.
Matt Skoufalos (Editor) August 05, 2012 at 11:42 PM
GFY, I chose to summarize McLoughlin's e-mail in large part because the content was a detailed discussion of the specifics of the incident in which Malik Clark got two technical fouls. Where the coach is quoted above is where it makes sense to explain his perspective on the incident. "All the quotes are from Oswald" not because there's any bias, but because this is the first time we as the public have a glimpse into the exchange between the two parties. And there weren't just e-mails between those two. Did you read where I explained that another e-mail was from Oswald to the Haddon Heights A.D. clearing McLoughlin of player recruiting? You're entitled to your perception of the story, and you're entitled to your opinion, but I will defend any charge that the details here have been presented with bias towards one side or another.
GFY August 05, 2012 at 11:53 PM
Yes, Matt. I saw the reference to the email to Haddon Heights. But most of them were about Oswald's emails. Please don't make it out to be my perception problem. This is definitlely Oswald's side of things, and I'm not blaming you for that. He gave the interview so obviously it's his side.
Matt Skoufalos (Editor) August 06, 2012 at 12:04 AM
Tell you what, GFY, I won't make it out to be your perception problem if you don't "whatever" me when I tell you something that's factual. I know where the e-mails came from because they were sent to me.
GFY August 06, 2012 at 12:13 AM
Haha.Okay,Matt. Do you have kids? Only a parent rerfers to "whatever" as a verb, as I have many times. I know you know where the emails came from and I know you can't say.
Matt Skoufalos (Editor) August 06, 2012 at 12:24 AM
I am, and I know, sadly, that the clock is ticking until the first of those days...
Mike King August 06, 2012 at 03:42 AM
Dear J. The BOE in Trenton has been appointed by the mayor for years, and its definitely corrupt. I'm not in favor of appointed BOEs but after 13 years of teaching in Jersey, I'm not all that impressed w/elected boards either. Especially when they completely ignore the huge public outcry of the stakeholders they purport to serve, obscure the real reasons for terminating teachers, and in general let kids and teachers pay the price for their incompetence year after year. I'm not saying Christie has the solution but he is making inroads in attaching consequences to administrators. Thats new. As far as the ability of NJ educators to address the needs of NJ students school system
Mike King August 06, 2012 at 03:44 AM
Sorry - I was trying to say I agree with you - we rock!
CBW August 06, 2012 at 02:12 PM
it doesn't matter how many wins he had if he is being prejiducehe shouldn't be coaching... end of story. this isn't the NBA it's HS Ball and everyone should have an equal chance to play
Mike King August 06, 2012 at 04:26 PM
PS the e-mails Matt S. referenced above were probably OPRAed. Any one can request copies of e-mail bet. teachers, BOE, and/school admin. from the district Business Administrator.
Joanna Mills August 06, 2012 at 05:06 PM
Okay boys, ya ready for this one? I need to paraphrase Allen Iverson here: "We're talking about basketball man? Basketball? We ain't talking about the game" When are we going to drop the basketball program? After all, it has one of the lowest performing group students academically taking part in it and THAT is what high school is supposed to be about first right, academics? High school is NOT about creating your athletic "glory days" to be talked about years from now at a bar as the highlight of your life. "Oh, do you remember that game..." And before anyone can claim that there are valuable lessons to be learned on the court - yes there are but HELLO they are secondary to the classroom! I can see the wave of testerone swelling out there right now ready to come crashing down on this post and cry foul. "How could you suggest ...!", "You must never have played..." well I can suggest it and I did play in school. But it was ALWAYS grades first. Perhaps the parent and community focus on this sport/subject is one of the reasons that CHS is a less than average academic school. Go look it up when you get done working on your 3's.
Mike King August 06, 2012 at 05:46 PM
Good one Joanna. Because poor academic performance is the real reason the supt doesn't want the coach recruiting Camden players for the team. While they rule on the b-ball court, he doesn't the resources (basic skills instructors) to bring up their test scores in the classroom. And, as everyone knows there are 41 sub-groups required to pass AYP, including one to measure the progress of African American students. If Collingswood fails to pass even one sub-group, you will fail to meet AYP entirely. This puts all of state funding in jeopardy.
B August 06, 2012 at 06:01 PM
Not crying foul because of love for the sport but because your ignorance to the meaning. For many students that have graduated at collingswood and students that will in the future, basketball has given them an opportunity to go on to the next level of education. The scholarships that are out there for basketball players are their ticket to getting an education they couldn't otherwise afford. And it doesn't have the lowest performing students- they work just as hard in the classroom and shame on you for suggesting otherwise. Maybe instead of losing the basketball program we should lose the ignorant feminist. That's you.
Joanna Mills August 06, 2012 at 08:22 PM
@ B - I'm going to ignore your name calling as a way to present an intelligent point of view. I fully understand that any woman that attempts to challenge some guys ego and sport is a feminist and just doesn't "get it". Riiight. Basketball/sport is their only way out. Really! Why is that? Why can't they just as competive in the classroom as they are on the court. Because they don't WANT to. Because the competiton is too tough. Oh and don't give me any of that socio-economically deprived nonsense either. We spend more money per student, have a better student/computers, student/teach ratios, and on and on than local schools yet how do they rank academically? If these kids (and their parents/guardians) really really wanted to get out of their situation they would find a way other than the very long odds that an athletic scholarship MIGHT hold. They would use their brains which lasts alot longer than their physical ability ever will. @ Mike - Thanks. But is AYP an issue still? CHS is not part of NCLB, thankfully, any more therefore AYP doens't apply. Dr. Oswald - field us a team of true student athletes. Kids who maintain A's and B's year round, maybe take a honors class or two. THAT is a team, and coach, I would heartily support. By doing so, I bet you would motivate those C and D students to pick it up in the classroom.
B August 06, 2012 at 08:33 PM
Not everybody is an A or B student and there never will be a day when every one is. To say that getting a C, even though they worked their hardest in the classroom, isn't good enough for them to do what they love makes no sense. How much we spend per student has no effect on the cost of college. Your lack of understanding of other peoples lives is very evident in your posts. Nonsense? Educate yourself. And while you're at it, get off your high horse.
Mike King August 07, 2012 at 04:11 AM
You're right Joanna. I should have said HESPA. With the coach recruiting Camden players, it fell upon teachers and admin to remedy their academic deficiencies and prepare them to pass HESPA. Academic failure will result in loss of state funding and possibly more.
jerry sandusky November 03, 2012 at 06:37 PM
give us mcloughlin!!!!


More »
Got a question? Something on your mind? Talk to your community, directly.
Note Article
Just a short thought to get the word out quickly about anything in your neighborhood.
Share something with your neighbors.What's on your mind?What's on your mind?Make an announcement, speak your mind, or sell somethingPost something